12 Comments
User's avatar
Jerry Hall's avatar

Now I'm glad I hadn't seen this movie yet, especially after reading Samantha Youssef's critique. Knowing you as incompletely as I do, the last trait I would ever associate with you is saviorism. If anything, and the thing I think is most important to know about you, is that you are a man following his conscience with sincere curiosity and scholarship, and with dedication and persistence. Hopefully your critic(s) take the time to get to know you better. My bet is they will see these and similar traits for themselves.

Tom Hall's avatar

Thanks Jerry, that’s very kind!

𝓙𝓪𝓼𝓶𝓲𝓷𝓮 𝓦𝓸𝓵𝓯𝓮 (𝓜)'s avatar

You made the right choice. Never doubt that. Talking to said person privately accomplished more than pushing back in the moment would have. Bravo!

DSM's avatar

Just watched the clip with Samantha Youssef linked in a comment below and learned so much--thank you for introducing her and the work that she's doing to your readers! As a Palestinian, and as a human, I thank you very much Tom for all of your advocacy. As the Israeli genocide of the indigenous Palestinian people continues, as its supporters trip over themselves with bold-faced lies that would be comical if they weren't enabling the collapse of our constitutional and international legal systems on top of everything else, we should ALL be doing whatever we can to end this nightmare, just as you are. Thank you.

Tom Hall's avatar

Thanks for the kind words, D! She has done a number of really good deep dives on different films with Dr. Jared Ball on the YouTube show IMixWhatILike that you should definitely check out too. Some of them are very long and not edited, but really educational.

DSM's avatar

Yes! Making my way through them. She's great--connects all the dots with her insider knowledge. Learning a lot and will share.

DEREK HANDS's avatar

There will always be haters. I have to speak up for the downtrodden. My conscience won’t allow me to do otherwise. Have been doing it since school days when I stood up for the bullied there.

Tom Hall's avatar

Fully agree but I don’t think that’s what happened here. On the contrary I’m pretty sure the person who criticized my action believes I betrayed the memory of Hind by not pushing back in the moment.

Amira Berzi's avatar

Look forward to reading your post about it. Curious to know why you think that movie is Hollywood propaganda

Reem Ayouby's avatar

Samantha is brilliant! Here is another talk of hers on this topic. Highly recommended.

https://youtu.be/dRQ_PGSfRSA

Tom Hall's avatar

I concur! I had intended to watch that live but I had a conflict. The recording is well worth watching, though.

Tom Hall's avatar

ICYMI I put a link to my original post on the topic in the footnotes. https://webzetetic.substack.com/p/hollywood-lies but the analysis is 100% from Samantha Youssef, and in her discussion on the topic with Jared Ball she goes really in depth on it. Well worth watching it all.